What's new
Apple iPad Forum 🍎

Welcome to the Apple iPad Forum, your one stop source for all things iPad. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Reasons why 'not' to buy 3G..

Wetstuff

iPF Noob
Joined
Apr 30, 2010
Messages
65
Reaction score
0
Location
Salisbury Maryland
Many people are certainly rushing the retail counter and as hot a ticket the iPad is, I think I found one good reason not to buy one: a weak 3G signal.

I have had mine for a few weeks now and realistically could have done without. I have been a Mac user since the late '80's .. run three at my business and have a Powerbook Pro ... and I will not be selling my iPad, but it will be collecting a bit of dust.

For me - the perfect use for the iPad is for a 'home' computer ..that slips into a small bag and carries but does not need to run Photoshop CS5. It would be perfect for my wife who has a lot of distant friends where she could check/send email anywhere she happened to be. There's no way she would, or need, to carry the PBP for her uses.

I would probably buy another iPad had it worked out that way. (Actually, this was to have been the camel's nose under the tent to convince my wife to convert both my business and home to iPhone and give the stalinists at Verizon the boot.)

My home however is on the fringes of the signal. So far, I have spent about $450 to get an antenna and repeater to snag a signal with little to show for the effort. The iPad works perfectly at my shop, but this iMac is already well connected via DSL.

I went to Los Angeles for a few days a week before the iPad came .. and it would have been a helluva lot better to travel with it vs. the MBP .. especially given all the space and luggage limitations of air travel these days. If I traveled more than a few times a year, that alone would justify the purchase.

I do not live a 'poor me' life. I give almost anything a 100% effort if it shows promise. If not, I look forward to the next adventure.

...but if someones asks you: tell them to make sure they get a good signal - a really good signal.
 

yvrgal

iPF Noob
Joined
May 24, 2010
Messages
216
Reaction score
0
Location
Vancouver
Website
www.vancouverjazzproject.com
I cancelled a 3G order when I first placed my order on the 10th and just opted for the WiFi. I have 3G connection already on my iPhone and I jailbreaked it to get MyWi. MyWi connects flawlessly to my iPad. So far this weekend because of the rain, I haven't gone anywhere but stay home and enjoy the WiFi connection from my router.

I get e-mails already from my iPhone. If I need to go online on my iPad, I just connect to MyWi if I'm traveling. That is if I get a 3G connection. Worst comes to worst, I can always go in a Starbucks or Blenz for WiFi access.
 

NumbLock

iPF Novice
Joined
May 2, 2010
Messages
2,008
Reaction score
32
Location
Switzerland
I went ahead and bought the 3G because I wanted the flexibility, and the GPS.

Disadvantage: a little more expensive
 

spinfreak

iPF Noob
Joined
Apr 20, 2010
Messages
87
Reaction score
0
Location
Fort Lauderdale, FL
I use the 3G network quite a bit...much more than I had originally thought I would. I'm finding that when I'm home, I'm usually reaching for my iPad instead of my laptop, but then I'm connecting to my wifi signal since it's faster. However, When going out, I'm bringing the iPad with me more and more, and I almost always use 3G then. And I rarely have less than a full signal. Even when driving on the road, whoever I have in the truck with me is using the iPad, and the connection is always strong, even on the highway.
 

DavidNM

iPF Noob
Joined
Mar 22, 2010
Messages
548
Reaction score
0
Location
NW New Mexico
The 3G costs an additional $130. That's it. If you have a weak signal at home don't turn on 3G.

I live very rural - I can get an 'edge' connection where I live - but the download speeds are about 30K.

On the other hand - during the first month I had my iPad I had to travel to a city of 80K people and ended up getting stranded due to weather for 3 days. During those three days I used 470mb of 3G service moving about the city. I was really glad I had the 3G. Doesn't mean I need it all the time - I'm in the process of moving the package to teh $14.99 package - and will bump up if necessary depending upon usage.

You never know when you'll need the 3G - and for $130 it's worth it to me.
 

Matth3w

iPF Noob
Joined
May 26, 2010
Messages
2,017
Reaction score
2
I rooted my Verizon Droid..so I get the WiFi tether from a GOOD network...for free (well for no more than I Already pay for monthy service).
 

Bremen

iPF Noob
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
1,350
Reaction score
5
Location
home
Website
www.bremencole.com
Like others I just JB my iPhone and tether.... I already pay $30 to AT&T for 3g for the iPhone, I thought it would be a waste to give them another $30..... I should point out that I am rarely out of WIFI when I need to use the iPad.... Seldom use the tethering, but it's there when I do need it....
 

MikesTooLz

iPF Novice
Joined
May 7, 2010
Messages
2,361
Reaction score
20
Location
Miami, FL
Website
Weather.Team
I rooted my Verizon Droid..so I get the WiFi tether from a GOOD network...for free (well for no more than I Already pay for monthy service).

dont know about your area, but here in Miami, Florida. I did speed test with the ipads built in 3G and my Verizon MiFi.

Att 3G on the iPad out performed the Verizon Mifi for connection speeds.

I would however say that verizons network seemed more reliable.
 
Last edited:

Matth3w

iPF Noob
Joined
May 26, 2010
Messages
2,017
Reaction score
2
I rooted my Verizon Droid..so I get the WiFi tether from a GOOD network...for free (well for no more than I Already pay for monthy service).

dont know about your area, but here in Miami, Florida. I did speed test with the ipads built in 3G and my Verizon MiFi.

Att 3G on the iPad out performed the Verizon Mifi for connection speeds.

I would however say that verizons network seemed more reliable.
There isn't a 3G ATT signal within an hour and a half of me. I used to have ATT here and it was the worst service ever. You can't even buy an ATT phone anywhere around here.
 

MikesTooLz

iPF Novice
Joined
May 7, 2010
Messages
2,361
Reaction score
20
Location
Miami, FL
Website
Weather.Team
I rooted my Verizon Droid..so I get the WiFi tether from a GOOD network...for free (well for no more than I Already pay for monthy service).

dont know about your area, but here in Miami, Florida. I did speed test with the ipads built in 3G and my Verizon MiFi.

Att 3G on the iPad out performed the Verizon Mifi for connection speeds.

I would however say that verizons network seemed more reliable.
There isn't a 3G ATT signal within an hour and a half of me. I used to have ATT here and it was the worst service ever. You can't even buy an ATT phone anywhere around here.

yeah depends where you live, ATT is big here.
I hate both ATT and Verizon but not much options. T-mobile just recently got 3G.
 
OP
Wetstuff

Wetstuff

iPF Noob
Joined
Apr 30, 2010
Messages
65
Reaction score
0
Location
Salisbury Maryland
MTL ... Pop. density is the deal. In Miami 25 acres is a Wildlife Sanctuary or a VL housing complex .. on my road it is one house. (Nothing too fancy - it's not Coral Gables up here.) Verizon does not even deem our land lines worthy of an electronic switching station upgrade so we can get DSL.

There is also the reality that there is more money to be made in a ghetto than the country. They'd rather slam poor people with payday loan-like fees than provide service to people 10 miles out.

.... it will come. Rather than the old days of Ma Bell when there was mostly only one game nationally, these cellular providers do attempt to compete - albeit half heartedly. We will need a Carlos Slim to step up Tracfone or one of the Asian Billionaires who now run networks of massive numbers seeking high market penetration rather than the top dollar, skimming system we now have. Cheers.
 

henry2

iPF Noob
Joined
Mar 28, 2010
Messages
800
Reaction score
6
Location
westcoast
i think the fact there is no extra bill comeing at the end of the month for a service that half the times does work right in the area iam in..some of my friend who have the 3g verison say that it not really worth the extra money for the 3g service intill they can get a better carrier for it ..
 

Most reactions

Latest posts

Top