Welcome to iPadForums.net Guest - Click Here to Register

Ipad Killers? What do you think?

This is a discussion on Ipad Killers? What do you think? within the iPad General Discussions forums, part of the Apple iPad Discussions category; Checked out the Samsung Galaxy tab recently. I actually saw it in a Costco store in Canada. Looks neat but there two big drawbacks for ...

iPadForums.net is the original Apple iPad Forum! Registered Users do not see these ads. Please Register - It's Free!
+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 40
  1. #1
    iPad Junkie!
    Member #
    7131
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    187

    Ipad Killers? What do you think?

    Checked out the Samsung Galaxy tab recently. I actually saw it in a Costco store in Canada. Looks neat but there two big drawbacks for me; I think you have to sign up for service as you would a phone and the second is that I am not so sure about the apps available for this device.

    I have pretty much got accustomed to several apps that I use in my job as a teacher using the ipad and I am not sure these same apps or similar ones will be available for the new Tab.

    The size too is a concern but I could get over that.

    I think there is also the Motopad and Playbook.
    What do you guys think about these so called killers?

  2. Ads


  3. #2
    iPad Addict
    Member #
    456
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Location
    Asia
    Posts
    1,252
    hi, for business reason we have a Galaxy Tab for almost 2 month one of the biggest complain is the lack of app’s and the second is the response time compare to the iPad …

    Web surfing is a little better than a mobile due to the size
    other than this reading eBook is not that good … this devices is more like a mobile and a OLD PALM than a real tablet of the 21 century …

    concerning the Moto and PlayBook , i think at the beginning they will have the app’s problem, as yet we can’t judge them only based on the data …

  4. #3
    TJK
    Guest
    For some the reason the whole "iPad Killer" nomenclature just annoys me. Build a device...at the right feature set, performance, and price it will find an audience.
    Even Google CEO Eric Schmidt has been quoted as saying that the Android OS is not optimized for tablets and from what I have seen I would have to agree. However, Chrome could be a very powerful tablet OS.

    I think the genius of the iPad is also what draws the most fire from critics: it is defined more by what it does NOT do than what it does. It does not have an SD card slot, it can't talk to external storage media, etc. But the "lack" of those features keeps it simple, solid, and fast.

    IMHO the only company that will be able to come close to the Apple iPad in the near term is RIM with the Playbook. Blackberries are rock solid choices in the business world and in large part that is due to the fact that, like Apple, RIM controls the hardware, OS, apps, everything. There are not 15 or 16 versions of iOS or RIM OS out there (like Android) and there are not potentially thousands of different hardware manufacturers running different microprocessors, ram, screens ,etc. It is the same problem that MS has with Win7....people complain about the bloat but they must be compatible with any system, hardware, peripheral and the literally countless permutations thereof. How many of us ***** about our PCs when really it is a poorly designed peripheral or driver that is bringing the system down?

    RIM and Apple, I believe, are successful for much of the same reasons. Controlling the platform and access to the platform gives you a much better chance of enhancing the experience for the customer.

  5. #4
    iPad Fan!
    Member #
    24114
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Posts
    9
    I have had both and prefer the Ipad.

  6. #5
    Administrator
    Member #
    1596
    Liked
    335 times
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Brisbane , Queensland Australia
    Posts
    5,312
    Tjk I like your response I do not like the word killer one is comparing 2 form factor of devices sure it is competition however as I stated in another post it is about choice. If the shoe fits wear it users buy any consumer devices for their personal reason. Similar to phones. Many like contracts instead of paying outright for devices Example RIm's blackberry phones. A lot of problems users have are not about the phones, ipads, and other tablet devices it is the networks they use like AT&T. In Australia we can use any network we want and funny enough you donot get any where near the complaints here. I personally get enjoyment out of the variety of applications available for the ipad and what makes it cool and so great they work on the ipod touch , iphone and ipad. There are many here hate iTunes however for me it's heaven and again works with out hiccup on my Mac. Apple tv and all devices. I agree iTunes is a bit bloated however I am sure Apple will only make it better Apple made it easy for the masses that is a major reason for their success and as you pointed out they own the hardware and software RIM makes excellent solid products and yes they will sell mainly into the business corporate market as that is what they are good at. Having competitive products is healthy so in summary the next 12 months will be interesting to say the least. It can only get better
    Cheers Colin,
    Administrator
    Brisbane Australia
    Certified Apple Product Professional
    _____________________________


    iPad User Guide
    Forum Rules. Please Read.
    Hacking Section Rules

  7. #6
    STi
    STi is offline
    iPF Novice
    Member #
    13833
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Location
    RI
    Posts
    98
    I have both and like the Galaxy tab more.


  8. #7
    iPad Junkie
    Member #
    12657
    Liked
    4 times
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Area DM51
    Posts
    669
    Good post, TJK - Thanks

  9. #8
    iPad Addict
    Member #
    456
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Location
    Asia
    Posts
    1,252

    Smile

    Quote Originally Posted by TJK View Post
    For some the reason the whole "iPad Killer" nomenclature just annoys me. Build a device...at the right feature set, performance, and price it will find an audience.
    Even Google CEO Eric Schmidt has been quoted as saying that the Android OS is not optimized for tablets and from what I have seen I would have to agree. However, Chrome could be a very powerful tablet OS.

    I think the genius of the iPad is also what draws the most fire from critics: it is defined more by what it does NOT do than what it does. It does not have an SD card slot, it can't talk to external storage media, etc. But the "lack" of those features keeps it simple, solid, and fast.

    IMHO the only company that will be able to come close to the Apple iPad in the near term is RIM with the Playbook. Blackberries are rock solid choices in the business world and in large part that is due to the fact that, like Apple, RIM controls the hardware, OS, apps, everything. There are not 15 or 16 versions of iOS or RIM OS out there (like Android) and there are not potentially thousands of different hardware manufacturers running different microprocessors, ram, screens ,etc. It is the same problem that MS has with Win7....people complain about the bloat but they must be compatible with any system, hardware, peripheral and the literally countless permutations thereof. How many of us ***** about our PCs when really it is a poorly designed peripheral or driver that is bringing the system down?

    RIM and Apple, I believe, are successful for much of the same reasons. Controlling the platform and access to the platform gives you a much better chance of enhancing the experience for the customer.
    i agree with you when you compare RIM & Apple , but have one important point you didn’t consider , is RIM is not creative as Apple we have see their fail with the ‘’ Storm’’ , they also miss the media content … this can be a week point for them to arrive to be big challenger of course we should give them the time but currently Apple is far behind all is competitor in this point …. ,

    Have also one company can be a serious player in this field if they decide to enter with the right products is Nintendo, with they giant catalogue they can take a big share, they have long experience in handheld device of course they will need to enter in field where they never be in the past, but Apple did the same 3 years ago with the iPhone and we know the result

    Have also one player i am waiting they come is HP with WebOs, as this platform is a excellent base and HP also manage their Hardware i don’t think they buy Palm only for use WebOs in their printer


    Time will tell us, but i scare iPad will did like the iPhone be so far behind then nobody really arrive to catch him (even now 3 years after)

  10. #9
    Super Moderator
    Member #
    1583
    Liked
    52 times
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Oklahoma
    Posts
    2,522
    I read recently about the Galaxy Tab where it was evaluated against the iPad. It says a lot when even a year later, no one has really found a good counter to it. There are situations where one or another competitors is a better choice, but not any serious threat. With all the advances coming out with the iPad2, things may get a lot more interesting. Eventually someone will make a strong competitor, but it may be years. The iPhone is just now getting serious competition, and when Verizon gets the iPhone, there will be a strong growth in sales.

  11. #10
    iPad Enthusiast
    Member #
    3319
    Liked
    3 times
    Join Date
    Apr 2010
    Posts
    399
    STi,
    What is the factor that makes you prefer the Tab? I wasn't impressed with the netbook sized screen (1024x768 res.). Is it the smaller size that you like?


+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 ... LastLast

Links

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

Similar Threads

  1. Why I didn't wait for the iPad killers
    By leebase in forum iPad General Discussions
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 03-14-2010, 08:55 AM