GoodReader Wins: iPad PDF Viewer Showdown
iPad PDF Viewer Showdown
Originally Posted by Rasputina
from App Advice by Trevor Sheridan
http://a1.phobos.apple.com/us/r1000/...100x100-75.jpg GoodReader for iPad ($0.99) by Good.iWare Ltd. lets you read pdfs on your iPad in a full screen interface. Thatís not all though as the app supports most file types you can think of including iwork, ms office, txt, jpeg, html, audio, and video. On top of that the app can connect with your mail, dropbox, idisk, and more.
http://wp.appadvice.com/wp-content/u...r2-300x225.jpg Uploading the various files can be done in a few ways, and each one is easy and streamlined. For wirelessly simply connect via a browser as FTP or via Bonjour. You can also transfer files over USB through itunes. The interface to access your files, and the built in browser is straight forward.
Once you actually view your files the app provides full screen view of each file. The navigation isnít the smoothest, but easily manageable. You have to flick down or up pretty hard to flip the page, and there is no sitting viewing half of one page and half of another.
With that said this PDF viewer provides everything you could want in one for only $1.
http://a1.phobos.apple.com/us/r1000/...100x100-75.jpg Air Sharing HD ($9.99) by Avatron Software, Inc. lets you view any kind of file format you can possibly think of in a streamlined interface.
Connecting is effortless over wifi either via a web browser or bonjour. USB transfer is available trough iTunes. You can even print out documents directly from the app as long as you have a wireless printer.
http://wp.appadvice.com/wp-content/u...g4-225x300.jpg In testing the app does not print to printers set up wirelessly using an airport extreme base station. It has to actually be a wireless printers, and not just printers that you can print wirelessly from your your computer.
The UI is great, and super smooth to use. You can go through long pdfs effortlessly, and you can view part of two different pages at once like a true pdf reader. On top of that you have access to all kinds of FTP servers, excluding dropbox, but including mail.
The app provides the best interface, feature set, file support, and is also the most expensive. Unless you have a true wireless printer, and intend to use that feature the app is not worth the premium price because the other cheaper ones are so good.
http://a1.phobos.apple.com/us/r1000/...100x100-75.jpg ReaddleDocs for iPad (PDF viewer/attachments saver/file manager) ($4.99) by Readdle Readdle Docs supports every file format you can think of. You can connect wirelessly in a web browser or via Bonjour, and over usb via iTunes.
http://wp.appadvice.com/wp-content/u...e3-300x225.jpg The app has an identical feature set to Good Reader including support for mail as well as dropbox. You can view microsoft office, iwork, txt, images, audio, and video to name a few. The interface is well done though itís a bit of a hassle to turn pages, and you canít view parts of two pages at once.
You can view all of the files in full screen with easy navigation between files. Connecting to the various servers is easy as well as uploading the various files. Readdle Docs is very similar to Good Reader in almost every way. For $4.99 it just isnít recommended simply because of the comparison to Good Reader.
http://a1.phobos.apple.com/us/r1000/...100x100-75.jpg PDF Reader Pro Edition for iPad ($3.99) by iTech Development Systems is similar to the apps above, but only supports PDFs. Itís a pdf reader with no support for microsoft office, iwork, txt, jpeg, etc. With that said it provides the best reading experience of any of the apps for PDFs.
http://wp.appadvice.com/wp-content/u...r2-225x300.jpg You can transfer files wirelessly or over usb through iTunes. It also offers the feature of saving files from a web browser. Like all the rest itís easy to jump to certain pages, add bookmarks, and search for specific words. Also included is the ability to send e-mails from within the app, and can save attachments from mail.
The app features a streamlined UI, and easy scrolling through large pdfs. You can scroll to a stop in the middle of two pages. You view files in full screen, and the app can handle large pdfs well.
Overall PDF Reader Pro gives you a great interface for just PDFs. For $3.99 itís not worth it with more capabilities for $1 more in Readdle or for only $1 in Good Reader.
There isnít much of a difference between all four of these apps. To test the apps I added the full length pdf book of Frankenstein, a pages document, various jpegs, an audio file, and connected to mail and dropbox. There was no distinction in any of the apps in the loading of these items whether it was wirelessly or over usb through itunes.
The interfaces are similar, the feature set for viewing the documents are practically the same, and so are the connection options. Each one handles detailed images and long pdfs well. Downloading attachments in mail was quick, and connecting to dropbox was just as good. They also all save your progress on exit, have access to all of the files when offline, and support every orientation natively.
Air Sharing HD features wireless printing in very specialized cases, but lacks dropbox support. It features the most intuitive and streamline UI of the bunch, but is also $10. PDFReader Pro has all the same features as all the other apps, but is limited to PDFs only. It also lacks the ability to connect to FTP servers and mail accounts.
Readdle Docs and Good Reader were almost the same exact software in nearly every way. The interface is different, but both have the same feature set, and problems with easily turning pages. The biggest difference is that one is $4.99, and one is only $0.99.
GoodReader is the best value of this bunch giving you all the features you could want in a pdf viewer for only $0.99. Itís UI and page turning is a little clunky, but for $1 I think most iPad owners can live with that. All of these apps donít differ very much so you should go with the cheapest option if youíre looking for one on your iPad. The more expensive apps offer no great incentive over Good Reader to be worth more.
Found Antoher iPad PDF Reader Today - Smiley Docs - free to Launch
http://images.appshopper.com/icons/368/456815.png SmileyDocs 1.0
Price: Free, Version: 1.0 (iTunes)
SmileyDocs is a simple-to-use yet fully-featured iPad app that allows you to easily read and view all of you documents (with an option of maintaining the same hierarchical structure that's found on your PC or Mac). While targeted at PDF documents, it supports all major document and image types, such as .doc, .xls, .ppt, .html, .txt, .bmp, .png and more. There are two viewers integrated seamlessly into this app: one that uses the same engine as Safari, and the other that uses Quartz, and the choice is up to you, as to which you would like to use, for PDF documents. The latter makes it easier to navigate files (e.g. going back or forward via button or swipe, and seeking to any page), and supports larger file sizes the Safari engine may be unable to handle without slowing down or crashing. It is the default and preferred viewer for PDF documents - and the one I use personally.