I bought 2 iPads from Best Buy, exact same models and I decided to get the accidental warranty which I can return within a week. It came out to $290 for 2 years of coverage and the cashier basically told me that since the coverage isn't linked to a serial number, I can just use the warranty on whichever breaks first.
I did a bit of research and found out about Square Trade, which offers accidental coverage at only $95 for one year and $150 for two years.
Has anyone had experience with either companies? How does Square Trade confirm the legitimacy of the claim? Would I be able to buy one warranty to cover both the ipads?